• Home
  • An RRSP Loan Is Only Safe If You Never Need the Refund
An RRSP Loan Is Only Safe If You Never Need the Refund
By Christina Pentlichuk profile image Christina Pentlichuk
3 min read

An RRSP Loan Is Only Safe If You Never Need the Refund

The first payment on an RRSP loan is usually deferred 90 to 120 days after you sign, and the refund that's supposed to cover it won't arrive until spring. For someone on a steady salary, that gap barely registers. For someone whose income comes in commissions, bonuses or owner draws, that gap is where the plan lives or dies.

The usual pitch makes real sense. If you earn well into Ontario's upper brackets, every dollar you put in your RRSP comes off your taxable income at a rate that can top 50%. Borrowing lets you use contribution room you'd otherwise waste, and the refund knocks down a big piece of the loan. For a lot of high earners, that math holds up. What it quietly assumes is that your income will show up on schedule. When yours doesn't, the loan is only safe if you could pay it off from your regular cash flow and never need the refund at all.

The refund is a bonus, so plan as if it never comes

Here's an illustrative example. Say you borrow $20,000 at 7% over 12 months. Your payment is roughly $1,730 a month. At a marginal rate near 50%, your refund might land around $10,000, but only after you file, and it pays down whatever balance is left by then. Until then, every one of those monthly payments comes out of your own pocket.

Now picture a slow quarter. A deal slips, a client pays late, the business needs cash. You still owe $1,730 a month, and the $20,000 is sitting inside your RRSP. Getting it out means the withdrawal is taxed as income, tax is held back up front, and under CRA rules that contribution room is gone for good. You'd be paying tax at a high rate on money you borrowed to save tax at a high rate, plus the interest.

That interest isn't deductible either. Borrowing for an RRSP or TFSA doesn't give you the interest deduction that borrowing for a non-registered investment account can. Every dollar of interest is a straight cost against your return. If the loan runs at 7% and a cautious portfolio earns 4% in a soft year, you're paying to lose ground.

Test the loan against your leanest months

The useful question to ask is whether you could make all 12 payments from net income during your slowest stretch of the past few years, without touching savings you'd need for an emergency. If the answer is yes, the loan is a timing tool, and a good one. If the answer depends on the refund, a good year or a contract you haven't signed yet, the loan is leverage on top of uncertainty.

This matters even more if your home equity is the funding source. A HELOC usually carries a lower rate than a bank RRSP loan, which is why many homeowners around Grimsby and the Niagara region reach for it. It also turns clear equity in your house into debt backing a market-dependent account you can't easily reach.

Size the loan to what your cash flow can clear

You don't have to choose between borrowing the full amount and borrowing nothing. If you already have a cash contribution set aside, a small loan can top it up to cover the rest of your room. The tax benefit is nearly the same, and the debt is small enough that a rough quarter won't force your hand. Cap the loan at what your regular income can retire within the year, and treat the refund as money for next year's contribution or your emergency fund.

If your real goal is building wealth with borrowed money over many years, an RRSP loan is the wrong vehicle for it. Strategies like the Smith Manoeuvre™ use non-registered accounts precisely so the interest can be deductible, which changes the math entirely.

Getting this right depends on your own income pattern, your mortgage and the equity you're working with. If you'd like a second set of eyes before you sign anything, I'm happy to walk through your numbers with you and see what size of loan, if any, actually fits.


Sources

  1. RBC Royal Bank - RRSP Loan Calculator. https://www.rbcroyalbank.com/cgi-bin/personalloans/rrsp/rrsp-loan-calculator.cgi
  2. Manulife Bank - RRSP Loan. https://www.manulifebank.ca/personal-banking/loans/rrsp-loan.html
  3. MoneySense - Is an RRSP loan a good idea?. https://www.moneysense.ca/columns/ask-a-planner/is-an-rrsp-loan-a-good-idea/
  4. WealthSimple - 2026 income tax calculator for Ontario. https://www.wealthsimple.com/en-ca/tool/tax-calculator/ontario
  5. nesto.ca - Mortgage rates — fixed 5-year - 2026-10-08. https://www.nesto.ca/mortgage-rates/fixed/5-year/