Turn your mortgage into a wealth-building tool. Smith Manoeuvre strategies, tax-smart planning, and honest math from two Canadian mortgage strategists.
$60,000 From Your RRSP, $40,000 From Your FHSA: The $100,000 Down Payment Math
A $60,000 withdrawal from your RRSP turns into a $4,000 bill every year for 15 years, and most people find out about the bill after they've spent the money. A $40,000 withdrawal from a First Home Savings Account sends you no bill at all. Both can go into the same down payment on the same house.
That's the part many first-time buyers miss. The Home Buyers' Plan (HBP) and the FHSA can be stacked, which puts up to $100,000 per person toward your purchase. For a couple who both qualify, that's $200,000. The useful question is how much of that $100,000 your budget can comfortably carry once you own the home.
Put both accounts on the same baseline
Picture $40,000 coming from each account toward your down payment.
From the FHSA: You deduct your contributions from your income, like an RRSP. The money grows tax-free, and a qualifying withdrawal comes out tax-free. You never repay it. To contribute you can add up to $8,000 a year, up to $40,000 over your lifetime, and you need a written agreement to buy or build a qualifying home in Canada before you withdraw.
From the HBP: You can take up to $60,000 out of your RRSP tax-free. That limit was raised from $35,000 in the 2024 federal budget. CRA treats the withdrawal as a loan to yourself. Repayment usually starts in the fifth year after the withdrawal (for 2026 purchases under current temporary relief) and runs over 15 years.
The cash in your hand on closing day looks the same. The difference shows up afterwards.
The repayment is a real monthly cost
Here is an illustrative example. You take the full $60,000 through the HBP. Divided over 15 years, that's $4,000 a year you put back into your RRSP. If your partner does the same, your household owes $8,000 a year, roughly $667 a month, on top of your mortgage, property tax and utilities.
If you miss a year, that year's $4,000 gets added to your taxable income. At an illustrative approximately 37% to 43% depending on income level marginal rate, which is close to where Ontario's top brackets sit, that costs you about $1,500 in tax. You also permanently lose that RRSP room.
The repayment goes back into your own retirement savings, so it isn't money lost to a lender. It still competes with every other expense in your first years of owning a home, though.
A refund can fund the next account
Contributing to your RRSP before a purchase produces a tax refund. If you send that refund into your FHSA, the same original dollars do two jobs. Under CRA rules, RRSP money generally has to sit in the account for at least 90 days before you can withdraw it under the HBP. Plan the order early. Unlike RRSP contributions, FHSA contributions must be made by December 31 to count for that year.
If your savings are invested, move them into something steadier as your closing date gets close. A market dip a few months before closing can shrink a down payment fast.
What $200,000 changes
Here is another illustrative example, using a $900,000 home in Grimsby or elsewhere in West Niagara. With 10% down ($90,000), you'd borrow $810,000. At 10% down, the CMHC mortgage insurance premium is 3.10% of the mortgage amount, which adds $25,110 to your loan. With $200,000 down, about 22%, you'd pay no insurance premium at all. You'd also borrow $108,000 less. In Ontario you may qualify for a first-time buyer land transfer tax refund of up to $4,000 provincial, or up to $4,475 if you buy in Toronto, which helps with closing costs.
You can also qualify again more easily than many people expect. You generally count as a first-time buyer if neither you nor your spouse lived in a home you owned in the current year or the previous four calendar years.
The condition that decides it
Fill the FHSA first. It costs you nothing later. After that, the HBP is worth using to the extent your budget can absorb the yearly repayment without strain. If $667 a month fits comfortably after your mortgage payment, using the full stack can save you tens of thousands in insurance premiums. If it doesn't fit, take less from the HBP and keep your first years in the house manageable.
Working through that number is easier with someone who sees these files every day. If you'd like to see how your own figures stack up before your next RRSP or FHSA contribution, reach out and we'll map it out together.
A $60,000 withdrawal from your RRSP turns into a $4,000 bill every year for 15 years, and most people find out about the bill after they've spent the money. A $40,000 withdrawal from a First Home Savings Account sends you no bill at all. Both can go into the same down payment on the same house.
That's the part many first-time buyers miss. The Home Buyers' Plan (HBP) and the FHSA can be stacked, which puts up to $100,000 per person toward your purchase. For a couple who both qualify, that's $200,000. The useful question is how much of that $100,000 your budget can comfortably carry once you own the home.
Put both accounts on the same baseline
Picture $40,000 coming from each account toward your down payment.
From the FHSA: You deduct your contributions from your income, like an RRSP. The money grows tax-free, and a qualifying withdrawal comes out tax-free. You never repay it. To contribute you can add up to $8,000 a year, up to $40,000 over your lifetime, and you need a written agreement to buy or build a qualifying home in Canada before you withdraw.
From the HBP: You can take up to $60,000 out of your RRSP tax-free. That limit was raised from $35,000 in the 2024 federal budget. CRA treats the withdrawal as a loan to yourself. Repayment usually starts in the fifth year after the withdrawal (for 2026 purchases under current temporary relief) and runs over 15 years.
The cash in your hand on closing day looks the same. The difference shows up afterwards.
The repayment is a real monthly cost
Here is an illustrative example. You take the full $60,000 through the HBP. Divided over 15 years, that's $4,000 a year you put back into your RRSP. If your partner does the same, your household owes $8,000 a year, roughly $667 a month, on top of your mortgage, property tax and utilities.
If you miss a year, that year's $4,000 gets added to your taxable income. At an illustrative approximately 37% to 43% depending on income level marginal rate, which is close to where Ontario's top brackets sit, that costs you about $1,500 in tax. You also permanently lose that RRSP room.
The repayment goes back into your own retirement savings, so it isn't money lost to a lender. It still competes with every other expense in your first years of owning a home, though.
A refund can fund the next account
Contributing to your RRSP before a purchase produces a tax refund. If you send that refund into your FHSA, the same original dollars do two jobs. Under CRA rules, RRSP money generally has to sit in the account for at least 90 days before you can withdraw it under the HBP. Plan the order early. Unlike RRSP contributions, FHSA contributions must be made by December 31 to count for that year.
If your savings are invested, move them into something steadier as your closing date gets close. A market dip a few months before closing can shrink a down payment fast.
What $200,000 changes
Here is another illustrative example, using a $900,000 home in Grimsby or elsewhere in West Niagara. With 10% down ($90,000), you'd borrow $810,000. At 10% down, the CMHC mortgage insurance premium is 3.10% of the mortgage amount, which adds $25,110 to your loan. With $200,000 down, about 22%, you'd pay no insurance premium at all. You'd also borrow $108,000 less. In Ontario you may qualify for a first-time buyer land transfer tax refund of up to $4,000 provincial, or up to $4,475 if you buy in Toronto, which helps with closing costs.
You can also qualify again more easily than many people expect. You generally count as a first-time buyer if neither you nor your spouse lived in a home you owned in the current year or the previous four calendar years.
The condition that decides it
Fill the FHSA first. It costs you nothing later. After that, the HBP is worth using to the extent your budget can absorb the yearly repayment without strain. If $667 a month fits comfortably after your mortgage payment, using the full stack can save you tens of thousands in insurance premiums. If it doesn't fit, take less from the HBP and keep your first years in the house manageable.
Working through that number is easier with someone who sees these files every day. If you'd like to see how your own figures stack up before your next RRSP or FHSA contribution, reach out and we'll map it out together.
Sources
Read Next
The Winter Market Isn't an Off-Season Compromise. It's an Audit.
Before Your Bonus Hits: The 5-Point Mortgage Prepayment Audit
The Early Mortgage Renewal Offer You Should Never Sign on Day One
Before You Sign Your Mortgage: The 4 Things to Negotiate Before You Invest